All Posts All Posts Business and Technology Business and Technology Education Reform and Sierra College Education Reform and Sierra College Changing the World + Adoption + Orphan Care Changing the World + Adoption + Orphan Care

Tax Rates Up, Revenue Down

Longtime readers of this blog will remember my opposition to tax rate increases to solve our mammoth state budget deficits. That’s because in an economic crisis like this, increasing tax rates will never collect the same level of tax revenues, and will almost always make the problem worse, since it disincentivizes the economic activity that produces tax revenue.

Sure enough, that’s what happened. In the first quarter, California’s tax revenues lagged projections by $300 million. Not a small amount of money, but if that trend had continued for the remaining three quarters of the year, we would have been short $1.2 billion.

Then the new tax increases went into effect on April 1, and the nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office just announced that tax revenues actually lagged projections by $1.8 billion dollars in April alone. That’s 6 times the rate of decline as the previous three months combined!

If this doesn’t cure those who believe that raising taxes is the solution to California’s massive budget deficits, you may be beyond help. :)

  • http://www.rhetorictorelevance.blogspot.com Karen Richmond

    You’re assuming that the people who believe raising taxes is the solution pay any attention at all to facts, logic or deductive reasoning. If they did, they wouldn’t have that opinion in the first place.

    • http://www.aaronklein.com Aaron Klein

      I’d like to think so, but I try to think the best of others. ;)

  • http://www.sierrageeks.com Douglas Keachie

    So raising California taxes caused the global economic decline and 500,000 serfs to lose their jobs last month? That’s powerful juju!

    • http://www.aaronklein.com Aaron Klein

      Nope, didn’t cause it — but it certainly made it worse.

  • David N

    California raising tax rates is a perfect illustration of Laffer’s curve. People take steps to avoid taxes when the rates go up. My wife and I are engineers. We make good middle class incomes and we were paying over $1000/month in state income taxes. We moved to Texas to two years ago. Almost the entire little suburb we moved to consists of California refugees.

    • http://www.aaronklein.com Aaron Klein

      Couldn’t have said it better. Thanks for commenting.

  • http://www.sierrageeks.com Douglas Keachie

    And do you like Texas as much as California? I personally need mountains, and really like the sea. I there was someway to move Colorado to Nevada and still keep the dry snow, I’d live there.

    • http://www.aaronklein.com Aaron Klein

      No, I love California. And I think our state is still hanging on solely because of our equitable climate and incredible natural beauty.

      But the higher taxes in this state are often the primary factor stopping small businesses from paying their employees higher and more livable wages. And we are seeing our jobs enter a one-way NASCAR race out of state as the taxes, regulation and bureaucracy have reached an apparent tipping point.

  • http://www.sierrageeks.com Douglas Keachie

    A rather good site for studying all this:

    http://www.taxfoundation.org/taxdata/show/336.html


Aaron Klein is CEO at Riskalyze, a Sierra College Trustee, and an adoption and orphan advocate. Most important: a husband and dad striving to live Isaiah 1:17. More »

Markets change. Do your investments still fit you?

Subscribe to the Blog via Email